Ubuntu Baba / Woolworths – who actually copied whom?

Everyone’s savaging Woolworths for copying Ubuntu Baba. Poor Woolworths! And, I’m not being facetious. I really mean: poor Woolworths. They only “copied” a “copy”. Is Ubuntu Baba new? No. Is it itself a “copy” of someone else’s infant carrier? Most likely. Is this bad? Not if making the copy is permitted – everyone copies someone; no-one develops in a “white box”. Don’t pillory Woolworths for making a legal copy. But if you’re idealistically bent on criticising large companies for being anti-small business, nail them for that, but not for copying.

Ubuntu baba woolworths

Let’s clear up a few misconceptions:

  • it’s legal to make and sell a 100% copy of a product that’s not patented or design registered. But, if you make a copy of a baby carrier, we suggest that you don’t unstitch the panels and trace them – rather take a ruler to the assembled bag. You may even buy the original product for the purpose of copying it.
  • it’s legal to use a competing product’s name as a Google Adword. Just don’t use your competitor’s trademark or product brand name in your Ad copy / text.
  • if you, as a supplier, have made a retailer sign a confidentiality undertaking in respect of your product, and you thereafter sell your product, the confidentiality undertaking will not prevent the retailer from: buying your product; copying it; and selling the copy. The retailer just can’t use other secret information you disclosed that cannot be gleaned from product you’ve sold.
  • a capitalist system encourages people who can copy, make and sell unprotected products cheaper to do so. If you pricing is too high, you will be copied and undercut.
  • applying for a South African design registration is not difficult or expensive. You can do so in 5 minutes and for less than $299. Just take photos of your product and upload them to GlobalIPCo’s online filing system. Within a day, GlobalIPCo will send you an official design application number.

Returning to Ubuntu Baba: on her Website, Shannon McLaughlin writes “With my baby comfortably asleep on my chest, I could finally continue my journey of Motherhood with peace of mind.” … implying that strapping a baby to her chest was “new”. Well, it wasn’t – let’s play spot the difference with this sample of earlier front baby carriers that took less than 5 minutes to find:

Ubuntu baba copy

Ubuntu baba copy

Ubuntu baba copy

Ubuntu baba copy

Ubuntu baba copy

Ubuntu baba copy

In removing its infant carriers from the shelves, Woolworths didn’t succumb to the law. It succumbed to what a small vociferous sector on social medial wished the law to be.

Read further: Understanding Design Rights

(Article sourced from https://www.facebook.com/iptica/)

Latest Specials
  • File provisional patent

    Only $49

    Learn more
  • Trademark search

    R3,600 + vat

    Learn More
  • Register a Trademark in South Africa

    R4,390 + vat

    Learn more
  • Online SA trademark filing

    Only $170

    Learn more
  • Save up to 70% on renewal fees

    Save up to 70% on patent renewal fees / annuities by paying them online

    Learn more

Contact us

Oaktree Corner
Johannesburg
South Africa

T +27 (0)83 627 1406 (trademarks)
T +27 (0)83 233 4582 (patents)
info@ideanav.co.za